Is a college degree necessary?

That title sounds like heresy, doesn’t it? Especially in our community where at least 90% of high school graduates pursue college. President Obama wants the U.S. to have the highest amount of young adults with a college degree in the world by 2020. There’s a growing debate, however, over the value of college for today’s students given the rising costs of higher education and our struggling economy. Is a college diploma still the requisite golden ticket to professional success?

“College shouldn’t be an automatic choice.”

Many argue that assuming every 18 year old should head off to college is a cookie cutter approach that fails to consider the different abilities and interests of the individual. Other options exist -like trade schools, two year programs or military service- that could be a better investment. Plus, drive, hard work and ambition account largely for a person’s success and those traits aren’t handed out with a cap and gown.

Ever met a kid that didn’t know what they wanted to do? Thousands of dollars can be invested on a lukewarm interest. Time spent in the “real world” may make a student more focused or motivated. The ivory tower will still be there.

“College is still the best option.”

Others argue that a bachelor’s degree is necessary to even be considered for many positions and having one will always ensure priority over other candidates. College graduates still have better earning potential than non- graduates and obviously certain professions can only be pursued with a college degree.

Besides the monetary viewpoint, many feel that the “collegiate experience” provides valuable intangible benefits. Young adults are exposed to different kinds of people and philosophies resulting in a more “well-rounded” individual.

Clearly both arguments have valid points and parents and students are left to evaluate the decision right for their unique situation. I have good friends who are on both sides of the equation with their two daughters. For one daughter school always came easily, she was driven academically and dreamed of careers that only a college degree could make possible. She is excited to be a freshman at the University of Kentucky this fall. Their other daughter, equally as talented, engaging and smart as her sister but not as academically inclined, is thinking her educational path will end after high school. She is considering a career in real estate. Fortunately, these two girls are blessed with parents who have the great wisdom to allow them to choose their own destiny.

With that kind of support, both girls are bound for success.

Column originally appears in Current in Fishers http://currentinfishers.com/